Pizza and Wings in Cumming: How to Order for a Table of Opinions

10/16/2026

Getting a group to agree on pizza is easy right up until somebody mentions the toppings.
One person wants meat. Somebody wants vegetables. Another person says they're fine with anything, then starts removing mushrooms. Add wings to the order and now you're negotiating heat levels, too.
We can't settle every dinner argument. We can give you a few useful places to start with pizza and wings at Good Ol' Days in Cumming.
Start with the pizza everyone will actually eat
Our G.O.D's Za is a 12-inch pizza with a mozzarella, Parmesan, and provolone blend and a choice of up to three toppings.
We make the dough and sauce from scratch and stone-bake our pizzas.
The topping choices give you room to build an order around the people at your table. The sensible approach is to agree on the main toppings before adding extras. A combination doesn't get better just because it usesevery available choice.
Look through the pizza menu together. Decide which ingredients are must-haves and which ones somebody really doesn't want. When opinions are too far apart, separate pizzas may be a better answer than a compromise nobody enjoys.
Ask about available options rather than assuming the kitchen can split every pizza into different combinations.
A named pizza can end the debate
When nobody wants to design dinner, the menu's set combinations do some of the work.
The Meat Pie puts pepperoni, Italian sausage, and bacon together. Margherita Style goes in a different direction with roasted garlic, tomato, basil, and cheese. There is also a Veggie Pizza for a table looking at the vegetable-heavy options.
Read the complete descriptions before ordering, especially when an ingredient or dietary requirement matters.
A familiar pizza name doesn't tell you everything about how a particular kitchen makes it.
Choosing from a set combination can be easier than collecting twelve separate topping suggestions.
Sometimes the best decision is simply making one.
Give the wings their own job
Once you've chosen the pizza, decide what you want the wings to add.
They might be the main thing for somebody who only wants a slice of pizza. They might be a shared starter. Or they might be the part of dinner everybody was looking forward to in the first place.
Agree on the sauce with the people eating them. A hotter choice isn't an upgrade when half the table won't touch it. Ask your server about current flavors and ordering options when your group has different preferences.
Don't order by headcount alone
A table of four isn't automatically four people with the same appetite.
Ask who's having a full meal, who's sharing, and whether anyone wants a separate entree. That conversation helps more than guessing how many slices each person will eat. It also keeps the person who said "I'll just have one wing" from accidentally becoming the reason the table needs more food.
Planning dinner around music or another event? Check the calendar and leave time to eat. Our Sunday Funday listings also feature pizza and wings; the current event page has the offer details.
Once the order is in, you can find something better to talk about than mushrooms.